Which assumptions about standpoint theory are NOT true?

1. A. Social position can give a privileged perspective on certain knowledge.
2. B. Marginalised groups may have insights the dominant group lacks.
3. C. The oppressed class is bound to lose class consciousness.
4. D. Marginal perspectives cannot help us understand social dynamics.
5. E. Social contradictions and political struggle can produce counter-hegemonic norms.

1. AA and C only
2. BD and E only
3. CB and C only
4. DC and D only

Pick an option to check yourself, or open the answer below.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: D. C and D only

Explanation

Hartsock, Harding: knowledge is situated, and the marginalised can see what the dominant cannot.